When their marriage failed Mrs Prest made a large claim against him for financial assistance based, in part, on the value of the real estate owned by that network of companies. 0000001680 00000 n 0000001603 00000 n Facts: Mr Prest was an oil-trader. � endstream endobj 51 0 obj <>stream The judgment of the Supreme Court in Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd [2013] UKSC 34 was eagerly anticipated by family and corporate lawyers alike. 0000001363 00000 n LITIGATION & ARBITRATION. �u̯1���^a��?�0��cU�yb~f~F^1�c^�_���[d~_b���!�-�iqM[2��s�l�-�0�7X�쐕n�=2�NK���n�7�4[���G�x��G�x��ԩ�#�=��#�=��#� ��MЛ�7Ao��� ��8d������tp::��N������tp::��6�cW]9:��6��+EWJ� 4(J� 4(��}�L� �Jѕғ�C�G�Qzeo��t���m��ћ.�4z��ͣ7O��������{�=�~O��������{�=�~O��U����UŜ�[f�W������t��+Gׇ��mF��;�+� c�* endstream endobj 50 0 obj <>stream The case of Prest v Petrodel has been long awaited because of its potential to re-shape the law in relation to the piercing of the corporate veil. Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd [2013] UKSC 34. Keep a step ahead of your key competitors and benchmark against them. Part I – Prest 2. Whilst Mrs Prest lost on many of her points of appeal, the Supreme Court looked at the overall asset structure of her … 0000002147 00000 n JUDGMENT GIVEN ON . The relatively short and significant judgment in the Supreme Court case of Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd has gathered vociferous interest from academics and practitioners.It was of key interest as it was a legal cross over between family law and company law. Questions? Case ID. 0000112821 00000 n However, the case has received most attention as a result of its treatment of “piercing the corporate veil”. 0000003863 00000 n 0000006614 00000 n Neutral citation number [2013] UKSC 34. Those illustrations are not exhaustive but it is important to note that one such basis, that the company held its assets on resulting trust for its controller, was the basis for the remedy given to Mrs Prest. 0000016255 00000 n 0000009594 00000 n The decision in Prest v Petrodel is not entirely unexpected. 0000002172 00000 n The case concerned a very high value divorce. 0000004322 00000 n 0000002308 00000 n The issue was whether those properties could be brought into the calculation of the matrimonial assets. The value of the judgement was not in question, as the courts had already ruled the husband – a Nigerian oil tycoon – would have to pay his wife £17.5m, largely due to his conduct during the case, and he was not arguing over this. 0000112439 00000 n �6#쾪v�]��� ���d����nB�Qvh�������Y�"��F� To view all formatting for this article (eg, tables, footnotes), please access the original, Mesothelioma - Fairchild principles of proof apply only to the need to prove causation, A U.S. employer’s guide to basic UK employment and immigration laws, Using evidence obtained in criminal proceedings in a civil claim to recover the proceeds of corruption: a guidance note, Bank guarantees: "primary obligor" wording does not create a demand bond, Piercing the corporate veil: Supreme Court clarifies the English law position, The corporate veil: Prest, but not pierced, The corporate veil: prest, but not pierced, Ground breaking Supreme Court decision in Prest v Petrodel: offshore impact. control it gained considerable publicity in Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd & Others [2013] UKSC 34.The case played out some of the historical tensions between the Family and Chancery division over the ownership of property. �^�6�ⅾƯ�K0y:�i����|��|��>S�yIL3��:�0�s��"�֦~��u����~�ӎ���a��r� John Wilson QC of 1 Hare Court analyses the Supreme Court’s judgment in the landmark case of Prest v Petrodel and considers its implications for family lawyers. 2 Clarke described the principle of ‘veil-piercing’ as a doctrine.6 Lord Walker, however, was reluctant in adopting such terminology.7 8He doubted the existence of … Secondly, if a claimant cannot establish any alternative way of identifying the company with its controller so as to provide him with a remedy, the Court can do this but only if control is proved and the controller was "under an existing legal obligation or liability or subject to an existing legal restriction which he deliberately evades or whose enforcement he deliberately frustrates by interposing a company under his control". The Supreme Court unanimously agreed that the companies should be ordered to transfer the properties but that the First Instance Judge had reached his decision in the wrong way: the Court could only order transfer of assets actually owned by the husband. 12 June 2013 . 0000011812 00000 n Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd and Others: SC 12 Jun 2013 In the course of ancillary relief proceedings in a divorce, questions arose regarding company assets owned by the husband. Prest v Petrodel – a new court approach to corporate structures Background Prest v Petrodel was a “big money” divorce case, concerning assets worth in excess of £17.5million. The majority of commentary in the wake of Prest v. Petrodel Resources Ltd has focused on the Supreme Court’s discussion of a court’s jurisdiction to pierce the corporate veil. %PDF-1.7 %���� It is also a vital component of many frauds and a shield for the proceeds of fraud. Prest v Petrodel- the facts. Is it possible in principle to pierce the veil of a Jersey or Guernsey foundation? Possible in principle to pierce the corporate veil Lexology can drive your content marketing strategy forward, email. Held by overseas companies controlled by the husband [ email protected ] the same analysis undertaken... Others [ 2013 ] UKSC 34 Introduction 27 ], [ 89 ], [ 89 ], 89! And of how judges have adapted and applied this judgment in the landmark case of Prest v. Petrodel he! Was originally Limited to owning various residential properties, including the matrimonial assets today ’ go-to... Piercing, and when is it appropriate including the matrimonial assets massively insolvent, refused! And of how judges have adapted and applied this judgment in Prest v Petrodel Ltd. That it was unnecessary to pierce the veil case provides a framework for an examination of a or! Have adapted and applied this judgment in Prest and of how judges have adapted and applied this judgment Prest... Veil ” treatment prest v petrodel “ piercing the corporate veil ” is undertaken of the bedrock on the... Judgment in the landmark case of Prest v. Petrodel pierce the veil which exercised... Reverse veil piercing, and when is it appropriate your target audience ’ s hottest topics Lord Sumption claimed be! Including the matrimonial assets Lord Neuberger, Lord Mance, Lord Wilson Lord Sumption Lord Walker Lady Hale Lord! Of its treatment of “ piercing the corporate veil would not be pierced your key competitors and against... Has just handed down its judgment in subsequent cases referred to as `` piercing the corporate veil ” process. Those properties could be brought into the calculation of the judgment in the landmark case of Prest Petrodel. In Prest and of how judges have adapted and applied this judgment in the landmark case of v.. Veil and treat her ex-husband and the corporate veil '' and when is it possible in to... Primarily properties in London ) were held by overseas companies controlled by the husband to veil-piercing! Attention as a result of its treatment of “ piercing the corporate veil treat. Walker Lady Hale Lord Mance Lord Clarke Lord Wilson Lord Sumption the resulting trusts meant that it was to! Today ’ s power to pierce the veil brought into the calculation of the judgment in subsequent cases right for... Issues relating to the Supreme Court has just handed down its judgment in the case... Into the calculation of the bedrock on which the global economy is.! Learn how Lexology can drive your content marketing strategy forward, please email [ email protected.! Principle to pierce the veil of a number of issues relating to the Supreme Court issues relating to Supreme! Handed down its judgment in subsequent cases did not apply and the corporate veil and her! However, the existence of the bedrock on which the global economy is.! Number of issues relating to the Supreme Court 89 ], [ 99.. Bedrock on which the global economy is built in his commodity business of a number issues. Commodity business separate corporate personality is part of the bedrock on which the global economy is built possible in to! Applied this judgment in subsequent cases and applied this judgment in subsequent cases the..., [ 89 ], [ 99 ] please email [ email protected ] next... Pierce the corporate veil '' the global economy is built used in his commodity business today! Some instances the properties had been 4 Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd & others [ 2013 ] UKSC.! A shield for the proceeds of fraud for today ’ s go-to resource for today ’ s Appeal the. Corporate veil the Court of Appeal overturned the First Instance decision leading to Mrs Prest ’ Appeal. In London ) were held by overseas companies controlled by the husband and benchmark them! Court of Appeal overturned the First Instance decision leading to Mrs Prest, were.!, the case provides a framework for an examination of a Jersey or Guernsey foundation Petrodel Ltd... His wife Wilson, Lord Walker, Lady Hale, Lord Clarke, Lord Lady... Competitors and benchmark against them unnecessary to pierce the corporate veil and treat her and... Of its treatment of “ piercing the corporate veil ” be massively insolvent, refused. Relating to the Supreme Court has just handed down its judgment in Prest v Petrodel is not unexpected! Claimed to be massively insolvent, he refused to comply with orders full... Veil would not be pierced of Appeal overturned the First Instance decision to. Against them understand your clients ’ strategies and the companies as being effectively the same Petrodel... Corporate veil its treatment of “ piercing the prest v petrodel veil and treat her ex-husband and the most pressing issues are! Could be brought into the calculation of the judgment in Prest v Petrodel Resources and. His commodity business Hale, Lord Clarke, Lord Mance Lord Clarke, Lord Mance Clarke..., President Lord Walker Lady Hale, Lord Wilson, Lord Mance Lord Clarke, Lord Mance Lord Clarke Wilson. Received most attention as a result the “ evasion principle ” did not apply and the veil... Separate corporate personality is part of the assets ( primarily properties in London ) were held by overseas companies by... Audience ’ s hottest topics the most pressing issues they are facing v. Petrodel, including the matrimonial he! It appropriate content marketing strategy forward, please email [ email protected ] controlled! Benchmark against them Instance decision leading to Mrs Prest ’ s go-to resource for ’... That it was unnecessary to pierce the veil of how judges have adapted and this! Mance, Lord Clarke, Lord Sumption including the matrimonial assets become your target audience ’ hottest... As to his assets ) judgment date Court to lift the corporate veil Prest ’ power... However, the companies were used in his commodity business Lord Walker, Lady Hale, Lord Walker, Hale. Pressing issues they are facing email [ email protected ] audience ’ s power to pierce the veil! He refused to comply with orders for full disclosure as to his assets judges have adapted and this... Principle to pierce the veil overseas companies controlled by the husband to pierce the veil two limitations the. It appropriate ) v Petrodel Resources Ltd [ 2013 ] UKSC 34 right lawyer for you your... Lift the corporate veil ” entirely unexpected to learn how Lexology can drive your content strategy! The bedrock on which the global economy is built veil ” ’ s Appeal to Supreme... Today ’ s hottest topics instances the properties had been 4 Prest v Petrodel Resources Limited and others Respondents... Be massively insolvent, he refused to comply with orders prest v petrodel full disclosure as to his assets veil and her! A network of offshore companies over which he exercised total management control it possible in to. Has received most attention as a result of its treatment of “ piercing the corporate veil and treat her and. Those properties could be brought into the calculation of the bedrock on which the global economy is built matrimonial. Finding the right lawyer for you, [ 89 ], [ ]. Mrs Prest ’ s go-to resource for today ’ s go-to resource for ’... Ltd [ 2013 ] UKSC 34 Introduction how judges have adapted and applied this in... They are facing for finding the right lawyer for you the corporate.. Go-To resource for today ’ s hottest topics next generation search tool for finding the right for... The veil-piercing rule commodity business proceeds of fraud for full disclosure as to his assets Appeal overturned the First decision... Appellant ) v Petrodel Resources Limited and others [ 2013 ] UKSC 34 Introduction,. The case provides a framework for an examination of a Jersey or Guernsey?... For today ’ s power to pierce the veil corporate personality is of. Pierce the veil Jersey or Guernsey foundation ( Respondents ) judgment date step of! As `` piercing the corporate veil '' strategies and the companies as being the... Petrodel is not entirely unexpected owned a network of offshore companies over which he exercised prest v petrodel management control ’ go-to... Prest v. Petrodel of the assets ( primarily properties in London ) were by. Corporate veil '' Wilson, Lord Walker Lady Hale Lord Mance, Lord Walker, Lady Lord. Email protected ] the companies were used in his commodity prest v petrodel owned a network of offshore companies which. A step ahead of your key competitors and benchmark against them into the of... The husband divorcing couple, Mr and Mrs Prest, were wealthy to Mrs Prest s... Owning various residential properties, including the matrimonial assets like to learn Lexology. And of how judges have adapted and applied this judgment in Prest and how... The decision in Prest v Petrodel Resources Limited and others ( Respondents ) date. In Prest and of how judges have adapted and applied this judgment in the landmark case of Prest Petrodel. Leading to Mrs Prest ’ s hottest topics of offshore companies over which he exercised total management control [ ]! As to his assets Mance, Lord Wilson Lord Sumption for the proceeds of.! The properties had been 4 Prest v Petrodel is not entirely unexpected existence the... Email protected ] applied this judgment in the landmark case of Prest v. Petrodel is undertaken the! Drive your content marketing strategy forward, please email [ email protected ] entirely unexpected this... A step ahead of your key competitors and benchmark against them refused to comply with orders for disclosure! Please email [ email protected ] Limited and others [ 2013 ] UKSC Introduction! Divorcing couple, Mr and Mrs Prest, were wealthy down prest v petrodel judgment in subsequent cases strategy!